Showing posts with label history. Show all posts
Showing posts with label history. Show all posts
Sunday, August 4, 2013
The Trouble(s) With Dissertations
It seems like most of the chatter among American historians has focused on two debates about the dissertation: should graduate students approach dissertation writing with the intention of having it ready for publication upon completion or is dissertation writing somehow different from book writing? AND should universities automatically embargo dissertations - that is prevent digital copies of them from being made available to scholars - or allow access to them immediately upon completion? I have largely remained on the sidelines for both debates for several reasons. I am in the early stages of my dissertation research and do not have much valuable wisdom to provide on either topic. I am not particularly interested in these kinds of debates and would rather argue about historical content instead of the politics of the history profession. But more than anything else, I have stood aside because I think the answer to both questions seems clear: allow the individual graduate student their own approach to writing their dissertation and choice whether - and for how long - they would like to have their university embargo it.
I am approaching my dissertation as a dissertation and not as a book. My dissertation is on the history of American China Studies and how it shaped and was shaped by mid-20th century American politics. While I feel it has the potential to have mainstream appeal, I am not sure that writing a book for a wide audience is the best way to present the significance of my argument or my skills as a historian to my peers. Fundamentally, I see the dissertation as a certification as to one's qualifications as a historian. Demonstrating these qualifications - ability to use archives, work in foreign languages, articulate a novel and significant argument - does not always make for the most compelling reading even for one's scholarly peers. Yet, I believe that it is important for my project and for my potential employers to demonstrate these skills, although doing so may mean substantial revisions (including cutting, adding, and rewriting chapters) when the dissertation is transformed into a book. The process make take more time, but I am confident in my dissertation prospectus and believe the final product will be well worth the wait.
Though I am not approaching my dissertation as a book, that does not mean every graduate student should avoid writing their dissertation as a book. At the Society of U.S. History blog, Rachel Shelden has given a litany of reasons why writing her dissertation as a book worked for her. Ultimately, each graduate student and their advisors and mentors must choose their own path. There is no "right" answer.
I feel similarly about embargoing dissertations; each student should be allowed to choose whether or not her dissertation will be embargoed by her university and for how long. Debate over embargoing dissertations was brought to the fore by an American Historical Association statement in June urging universities to embargo all student dissertations. This attracted criticisms from many historians who saw the announcement as a foolhardy commitment to the dying medium of print monographs and doing a disservice to young scholars and the profession as a whole by keeping the innovative work of young scholars out of the hands of their peers. Further arguments for the embargo have been forwarded since the AHA's initial announcement, most eloquently by former AHA President Bill Cronin. I understand this puts a lot of stress on university administrators and library personnel who have to process these requests. I understand that it is easier to approach embargoing with an all or nothing mentality. But in the end, the dissertation is the intellectual property of the graduate student who researched and wrote it and they should be allowed to restrict or provide access to it as they see fit.
There are some obvious pitfalls to this case-by-case approach. What if a graduate student forgoes embargoing her dissertation and it is never published as a result? What if a young author's work is preempted while her dissertation is embargoed? Shouldn't the university have some control over the dissertation seeing as they provided at least some of the financial and material support necessary for its completion? Though these issues may seem significant - and indeed many are - the fundamental point remains that neither the AHA nor the university should be compelling graduate students to either embargo or not embargo their dissertations. The choice should remain their's and their's alone. Historians differ in how they want their work to reach their target audience. Some may want their dissertation to be published as a book, others may not want an academic career and therefore do not see the need to revise their dissertation and make it a book. All of these approaches are valid and the university should be compelled to respect all of them, even if they're inconvenient.
To me, both of these controversies point to the continued employment crisis facing young historians. With their traditional means of ideological dissemination (the print book) and their workspace (the university) contracting, even as the number of graduate students continues to grow, the uncertainty facing young scholars adds urgency to debates that to outsiders may seem like small potatoes. After all, writing dissertations as books and embargoing dissertations are only relevant issues if there continues to be a publishing industry looking to publish those books and universities looking to hire their writers. Despite their seeming insignificance, both debates highlight the one thing the graduate student does control in this unstable professional climate - their own work and ideas. If control over those ideas and their form is taken out of the young scholar's hands, be it by the university or the AHA, then there is nothing left for the young historian or the future of the profession.
Friday, March 29, 2013
The Arc-Hive Mind?

I have spent this past week conducting preliminary research for my dissertation prospectus at the National Archives II in College Park, Maryland. While there I had an epiphany (of sorts) about the problems academic historians have reaching a broader public. Unlike, other critics that point to the difficulties presented by academic writing or stress that the nuance of academic histories are too much for the “average” reader (whoever that is), I think the problem is the archive or rather, the relationship between academic standards of evidence and narrative.
Two interrelated events led to my epiphany. Working at a massive research facility like Archives II, I was confronted by a dizzying array of brilliant historians and archivists. Everyone had a thoughtful research project. The reading room resembled a historian hive with researchers buzzing between carts, computers, and copy machines. The collection of source material divided into its binders, folders, boxes, and carts was overwhelming. But one thing was missing: narratives. There was no box labeled “Narratives” and you couldn’t find it searching through the online database (believe me, I tried).
After a long day at the archive, I was killing time in Dupont Circle before meeting friends for drinks. I wondered into Kramerbooks and Afterwords - a charming independent bookstore – and began browsing their history new releases section. Being a poor graduate student and an AmazonPrime Member, I rarely peruse the new history releases and was shocked by how few names I recognized despite being a professional (in training) historian. Flipping through books by Mark Kurlansky and other popular historians, I – again – noticed something was missing: the archive. Most of the evidence in the popular histories was from primary and secondary sources; unsurprisingly many journalists were partial to newspapers. These histories were overwhelmingly story-driven. The few histories I had read were from old or deceased academics like Hofstadter, Lasch, Schlesinger Jr., Zinn, and Woodward. It seemed as though the history academy had lost the popular support it once had during the 1960s and 1970s. But was their work really so different? Feeling confused, I walked out empty-handed.
I thought about all the hustle and bustle in the archives earlier in the day and wondered: where is the output from all this research going? Who is reading all the brilliant work produced by researchers at Archives II? How did popular historians come to fill the void left by academic historians of earlier eras?
Then I began to think of the archive. Hofstadter was notoriously archive-resistant. Lasch seems to have drifted from archival work as he became more of a public intellectual after the publication of The Culture of Narcissism in 1979. Schlesinger’s The Vital Center is almost entirely supported by secondary sources. I thought of all the little archive boxes filled to the brim with folders and wondered: are archives limiting our horizons as historians? This problem seems particularly acute with young historians who are trying to evince academic rigor to their senior colleagues. I remember writing my master’s thesis and building chapters around novel archival evidence instead of published material because I thought it would showcase my research ability. Narrative was often the last of my concerns or something I simply hoped would happen if I added enough biographical anecdotes.
Beyond limiting research, it also seems to exacerbate a bifurcation between academic historical research and politics. It seems to me that the archive creates another separate community – along with the academy and scholarly associations – that isolate academic historians from the public. Academic isolation has intensified the professorial argot, but more importantly it has led to group-think about what is important and how to communicate themes that academics believe are significant to a broader audience. I was shocked how few histories of race, sexuality, and gender were carried at a well-stocked independence bookstore (the ones that were carried being published by non-academic historians like Isabel Wilkerson). Military histories still predominate in bookstores and on television, despite its declining significance in the academy. As the Supreme Court debate over DOMA continues, the value of historical context to politics is readily apparent. Histories of gender and sexuality composed by articulate academics, if widely read, could help Americans understand why gay marriage is an important issue in the same way C. Vann Woodward’s The Strange Career of Jim Crow made legible the origins of the Civil Rights Movement.
Obviously, I think academic historians need to look beyond the archive and focus on storytelling to broaden our audience. Outgoing American Historical Association president William Cronon has already made this point in his annual address, so there is no point to belabor it here, but the question remains: how can professional historians be encouraged to publish books for public consumption while retaining high research standards? Though it will undoubtedly be a long and difficult process, I am confident an accommodation can be reached. It will mean, however, that historians will have to enter the scrum of politics where the rules of reasoned debate rarely hold. But getting a little dirty is a small price to pay for the transformative potential of academic historians acting as popular social critics.
Researchers at Archives II and other reading rooms across the globe have a tremendous wealth of information to share. It is time we began to focus on communicating that information to the widest popular audience. To accomplish this, researchers will need to leave the arc-hive and venture out with their knowledge to pollinate the world.
Monday, March 25, 2013
Finding My Vital Center Or, a Liberal Fever Dream

Riding eastbound on a train from Raleigh, North Carolina I was emotionally devastated by a surprising book: Arthur Schlesinger Jr.’s The Vital Center: The Politics of Freedom. While I was moved differently from when I read a great work of fiction, I found myself vigorously underlining and exclamatory commenting my way through entire chapters of The Vital Center. I was particularly moved by his criticism of “Doughface” progressivism. Schlesinger’s attacks on the flabbiness and lethargy of progressive sensibility echoed with my own growing dissatisfaction with the naïve optimism in the far left I held in my teens and early twenties. Bouncing by the postindustrial wastelands of Wilson and Rocky Mount I couldn’t help, but wonder if America needed to revitalize its vital center politically and geographically.
Upon finishing the book, I tried to come to terms with why it hit me so hard. I didn’t even have to look past the title to get my answer. Now in my mid-twenties, I have never lived in a time when liberalism has had a center. I am a child of the age of fracture, an orphan of the culture wars. There is a part of me that longs for the perceived harmony of liberal consensus, a return to the simpler times of an imagined past.
As a privileged white male it is easy for me to long for the vital center. Robert O. Self has convincingly demonstrated how the vital center was founded on a white, male breadwinner ethos. Schlesinger admits to his 1997 introduction to The Vital Center that he neither paid sufficient attention to the burgeoning black freedom struggle or the contributions of women to liberalism (xiii-xiv). Still, there seems to be nothing in The Vital Center excluding non-whites or women from its political vision. In fact, a wholehearted embrace of its values – and in particular equal opportunity – could improve the domestic social situation of both groups.
Ultimately, The Vital Center is a relic of a bygone era. America cannot return to the centrist, liberal consensus of mid-20th century. The economic conditions do not exist to support such an optimistic vision nor does America’s declining importance on the global stage. Furthermore, much of the liberal consensus was founded upon injustice; on the sweaty backs of cheap labor abroad and the unpaid work of women at home.
My fever dream of The Vital Center expresses a longing not for the world of the 1950s, but for the values postmodern society is in the process of losing or has already lost: community, respect, trust, empathy, and solidarity. I have seen little of these values in my twenty-five years. I am hopeful I will see more of them in the next twenty-five.
Thursday, May 31, 2012
Nietzsche's American Noontide: A Review of "American Nietzsche" by Jennifer Ratner-Rosenhagen
Friedrich Nietzsche never traveled to the United States. He also rarely wrote about it and did not read most of the giants of the American literary canon (with the notable exception of Ralph Waldo Emerson). He scorned democracy and the quest for wealth as impediments to cultivating a strong self. Yet, somehow, Nietzsche has for over a century found a large, enthusiastic audience in America. Why have the writings of Nietzsche resonated with so many Americans from diverse backgrounds at disparate times in history? Why has his biography - unsuccessful writer turned madman - resonated so deeply with American intellectuals? In the most expansive study of American Nietzsche reception published, Jennifer Ratner-Rosenhagen demonstrates why Nietzsche and his philosophy have gained traction in the United States despite being at odds with many of its 'fundamental' values: democracy, Christianity, and capitalism.
American Nietzsche has both a broad temporal and thematic scope. Like other Nietzsche reception studies, most famously Steven Aschheim's magisterial The Nietzsche Legacy in Germany, 1890-1990, Ratner-Rosenhagen's scope spans the entire twentieth century. She begins with how Nietzsche was imported to America by a few radical, Germanophilic intellectuals at the turn of the twentieth century and rapidly gained a following with the publication of English translations of his major works as well as landmark studies of Nietzsche by some of his more famous early converts like H.L. Mencken. This reception accelerated and broadened as the century progressed. As elsewhere, Nietzsche's philosophy and personality were appropriated across the political, religious (Protestants, Catholics, and Jews), cultural (radicals and conservatives), and social (rich and poor, immigrant and native, intellectual and non-intellectual) spectrums for divergent purposes.
The broad penetration of Nietzsche's ideas in America is brilliantly demonstrated by Ratner-Rosenhagen in her chapter, "Devotions: The Letters". In it, she quotes from Nietzsche fan mail sent to Elisabeth Foerster-Nietzsche gathered at the Nietzsche Achiv in Weimar during the interwar period. The breadth of the letters is illuminating. Some, written by German immigrants and native Americans fluent in German, complain of the poor English translations of Nietzsche and request German language copies of his works. Others tell Elisabeth of how her brother's philosophy liberated them from American-Protestant slave morality or taught them the importance of self-strengthening (204). The most shocking letters come from one John I. Bush of Duluth, Minnesota who claimed to be "One who is evil enough" and a Nietzschean ubermenschen (206-207). By using fan mail, Ratner-Rosenhagen successfully demonstrates both that Nietzsche's readership was diverse and that readers used Nietzsche to better understand themselves and America.
One of Ratner-Rosenhagen's signal successes is cataloging the diverse reactions to Nietzsche without passing judgment on the interpretations. Because Nietzsche was such an outspoken critic, there is a tendency to appropriate his critical voice when assessing his reception. Ratner-Rosenhagen deftly avoids facile discriminations positioning certain interpretations of Nietzsche as superior to others. She respects the views of all the characters in her book, no matter how far-fetched their requisition of Nietzsche's philosophy might have been. This is especially impressive when discussing the impact of Walter Kaufmann on postwar Nietzsche scholarship. Kaufmann's palatable version of Nietzsche as "salonfaehig existentialist" has been hotly debated over the last few decades. Though all believe his Nietzsche is flawed, the question of whether or not his interpretation of Nietzsche has value in a post-Cold War world remains up for debate. Ratner-Rosenhagen ably avoids the Kaufmann morass by cleaving closely to his historical significance as savior and redeemer of Nietzsche's philosophy after World War II instead of his impact on current Nietzsche scholarship.
American Nietzsche is a beautifully written and thoughtful examination of Nietzsche reception in the United States, but it is not without its difficulties. First and foremost, is a problem of audience. American Nietzsche assumes a great deal of familiarity with Nietzsche's writings. Ratner-Rosenhagen never gives an overview of Nietzsche's philosophy or any of his major concepts aside from the uebermensch. This restricts the possible audience for the book to intellectual historians and Nietzsche enthusiasts who are already familiar with his philosophy.
Second, Ratner-Rosenhagen strives, unsuccessfully, the problematize American Nietzsche in order to make it more than a reception study. For Ratner-Rosenhagen, Nietzsche's popularity in the United States demonstrates both "how American encounters with Nietzsche ignited and revealed larger anxieties about the source and authority of truth and values in a modern pluralist society" and "incited and exposed long-standing concerns about the conditions of American culture for intellectual life" (23-24). In both these respects Nietzsche was far from unique and American intellectual insecurity has been explored ad nauseum at least since Richard Hofstadter published Anti-intellectualism in American Life in 1963. Ratner-Rosenhagen's attempts to problematize Nietzsche's American reception distracts from her attention on the actual reception. For instance, her most successful chapter on American letters to the Nietzsche Archiv is dwarfed by lengthier, though less substantial, chapters on the penetration of Nietzsche into the discourse of American church officials and on the New Radicalism. These chapters tell us little about Nietzsche's American reception, but do support her dual problematics.
American Nietzsche is an essential read for American intellectual historians and Nietzsche enthusiasts. It provides a concise, yet thorough, examination of how Nietzsche's philosophy challenged and was accepted by many prominent American intellectuals. It fills a gaping hole in the American intellectual historiography and in Nietzsche studies. At times, Ratner-Rosenhagen unnecessarily problematizes her argument to inflate Nietzsche's significance in exposing American anxieties and their
intellectual inferiority complex vis-a-vis Europe. Even with these small difficulties, American Nietzsche brilliantly delineates how one of Europe's most controversial and misunderstood philosophers achieved fame in a United States seemingly at odds with many of his fundamental concepts.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

